REVIEW: L'oreal Carbon Black Telescopic Liquid Eye Liner

Please ignore my stained nails!

No. Just NO.  This is not the kind of brush a liquid eyeliner should have:

Horrible, stiff sponge applicator

Pros: It is very black and washes off easily (not waterproof).
Cons: The brush/doefoot is wayyy too thick. It's nearly impossible to get a precise line.  The shape of the brush sheers out the black a bit so you have to go over the line again which just ups the possibility of making your line jagged.  It's extremely difficult to taper your liner to a point for a cat-eye, so I wound up taking the line out to Cleopatra-length.  That look has its place but it's hardly what I'd call versatile.
Repurchase? Heck-to-the-NO!
L'oreal Carbon Black Telescopic Liquid Eyeliner is $8-$9 at drugstores, but PLEASE save your money and don't try it!

Three failed attempts to get a thin, opaque line.

Into the bin with ye!