EOTD: Subtle Morning Sunrise with Stila loves Roxy (and a bonus quickie-review)

Hey'all! Quick EOTD to show the Stila loves Roxy palette on my eyes.  I was surprised that the peaches looked so similar on and more pigmented than my swatches suggested.  I started this EOTD with the face chart instructions, which just wound up being a waste because the peaches were muddled on my lids. I ought to have just tried the gradient look.  I used the shade "water" on my lower lashline, but I did find it a bit too sheer.  In person the effect is definitely a watercolor makeup look, but a lot of the pictures I took just made it appear to be blue under-eye circles!  This palette can't just be slapped on in the morning (in contrast, I wore Love and Empower yesterday, which looked just fine applied quickly and to face-chart specifications).
I'll do a redo-run with this palette tomorrow and I'm sure it will turn out better!

Winning: L'oreal Voluminous Carbon Black Mascara. Like the Roxy palette, it also takes a lot of care with application (to avoid clumping), but it is super-black and volumizes quite well - I just wish it had held my curl. Clinique Bottom Lash Mascara in Black  =  <3 ('nuff said!).

FAIL: Benefit Realness of Concealness Kit. First of all, it doesn't have a decent spot concealer, just Boi-ing, which I already see sliding off and creasing under my eyes three hours after application.  Ooh La Lift did diminish puffiness a little bit but I already have eye cream, moisturizer, foundation and concealer to put on, so why would I want to pack on yet another product?  High Beam is sooo inferior to Girl Meets Pearl (which I love). There is no discernable highlight on my cheekbones where I dabbed it. Lemon aid doesn't do anything to color correct on me (probably because I'm already kinda yellow) and is making my shadow crease. The Lip Plump is not bad, but to be honest I enjoy reapplying lippie. I would totally return this kit if I didn't get it as a GWP. End Rant/Bonus Review.